Program 13: Whither Islam?
The Future of the Islamic Resurgence
There
are two ways of looking at the current Islamic resurgence. Either
it is a passing fad, blown out of all proportion by the media and
tied to the rise and fall of the price of oil: or it represents something
altogether deeper and more permanent, if less spectacular. There are
few easy conclusions, but only half-answered questions: For instance,
is the Islamic revival merely a subtle new form of nationalism in
the Islamic world?
Or is it part and parcel of a much broader attempt to find solutions
to the problems modernization from within one's own traditions and
culture?
And how are we supposed to measure the success or failure of this
Islamic revival?
In terms of institutional change and political rhetoric or by mosque
attendance and religious dress?
Is this something that will come to fruition in a handful of years,
or should we measuring it in terms of generations?
Then
again, are we too preoccupied with what is happening in the Arab and
Iranian worlds to the exclusion of the experiments in, say, Malaysia
or Pakistan? Thus far, it's probably fair to say that the record of
achievement has been mixed at best: Nowhere, for example, is there
a state that is generally recognized by Muslims as purely Islamic.
And while the Shari'ah or divine law has been reintroduced in several
countries, too often the emphasis appears to be placed on the Hudud
or punishments - such as amputation for theft - rather than on the
liberating or merciful nature of Islam. There appears to be an equally
excessive preoccupation with prohibitions in social and sexual matters.
In the economic field, the alms tax or Zakat has been largely taken
over by the state. While interest-free banks are established in several
countries, few Muslim economists even believe they alone can hold
the key to economic growth. Most Muslim thinkers acknowledge they
will probably have to be part of a broader Islamic economic model
that looks to the present and future as much as to Islam's past. Is
there in fact a danger that, in their impatience to Islamize their
societies many Muslim countries may overemphasizing form at the expense
of substance?
Another unresolved question is whether Islam contains within itself
answers to the problems of the Twenty First century? Are its principles
sufficiently flexible to permit the necessary adaptation?
Is the current revival, as some insist, merely a final anguished cry
of despair on the part of peoples who have tasted too often the bitterness
of despotism, underdevelopment and failure? Or does it really signal
the renaissance of beliefs and culture that gave the modern world
much of its scientific and cultural glory? Finally, are we in the
West perhaps guilty of seeking out the spectacular revolution of the
street, when the full Islamic revival may be taking place in the quiet
of the classroom and the home all over the Muslim world? This final
program in our series is reported and narrated by Julian Crandall
Hollick.
People
interviewed in this program: Kemal Faruki, Mochtar Lubis,
Akhbar ul-Alam, John Esposito, Fuad Zakaria, Anwar Ibrahim, Muhammad
Saeed, Kemal al-Sharif, Anis Ahmad, Manzoor Ahmad, Agha Abdul Hamid,
Khalijah Salleh, Harun Nasution, Dawan Rahardjo, Sadiq al-Mahdi, Khurshid
Ahmad, Kamal Hassan, Hasan al-Turabi, Musa Keylan, Khalid Ishaq, Abubakr
Bagader.